bathwizard wrote:Bloodaxe, do you envision this just replacing magic users, or replacing clerics as well?
Kilgore, I like what you've done with the PDF spell lists, even if I don't recognise all the spells,
Thanks! All the spells on that version of the list are from Labyrinth Lord core and AEC, so nothing should be out of the ordinary. What might be throwing you is the fact that we took reversed versions of reversible spells and made them their own separate spell for this. No reversible spells here.
As for clerics and the spell list, the assumption was that all the standard spell caster classes would be removed and replaced with five color-based spell caster classes. The list includes cleric, magic-user, illusionist, and druid spells. I happen to like the way it results in five different flavors of spell caster, each of which is distinct but more or less equally "usable."
I have no doubt that anyone who uses this will adjust the list to their tastes. And we made an effort to make the number of spells equal. Some of them were sort of forced into their category. The list we use in our own game is similar to this but not the same. Some spells we tweaked the name and fluff to suit the color category better but kept the mechanics the same. Other spells were dropped, and some new ones were added.